If you didn't grow up in the late '80s or '90s, you missed what many gamers still consider the golden era of video games. This was a time when cartridges ruled, memory cards were sacred and sleepovers revolved around split-screen battles and trading Pokémon. These days with massive downloads, live service games and constant updates, it's easy to feel like something’s been lost. The phrase “they don't make it like they used to” hits especially hard in gaming and honestly, it's not just nostalgia talking.
So when you hear about a retro video game store opening in Modesto, you might wonder: can something like that really thrive in the Central Valley? Surprisingly, the answer is a strong yes and Cake Hoarders is proof of that.
A Hidden Gem on Standiford
Located next to the Le Reyna Meat Market on the south side of Modesto, Cake Hoarders has quietly become one of the most exciting spots for gamers in the area. Located at 2101 Standiford Ave, the shop opened in early 2025 and immediately started turning heads, not just because of what it sells, but because of how it feels.
Walking into the store doesn't feel like stepping into a typical game shop but instead it feels like entering a time capsule. Shelves are lined with everything from classic Nintendo cartridges to early 2000s consoles and there’s an energy in the air that’s hard to explain unless you've lived it. It's part museum, part marketplace and part community hub.
And that's what makes it special. This isn't just about buying or selling your old games. It’s about reconnecting with an era.
From Social Media to Storefront
The man behind Cake Hoarders, known online as Max, didn't just open a shop out of nowhere. He built a following of over 173,000 people by sharing his journey as a retro game reseller and collector. Over the past few years, his content has gained traction across platforms, attracting viewers from all over the world who share the same love for these classic games.
When he finally got the keys to his Modesto storefront, he documented the entire process. His goal? Open the shop in just 30 days. Through daily video updates viewers were able to watch everything from empty walls to fully stocked shelves. It turned what could’ve been a simple business opening into a story people felt invested in.
Now that the shop is open, his content continues to evolve. Instead of just documenting the build, he showcases rare finds, trade-ins and interactions with customers. It's a smart use of social media, not just for entertainment but as a powerful (and free) marketing tool that brings people through the door.
A Treasure Trove of Hard-to-Find Games
What really sets Cake Hoarders apart, is the inventory.
This isn't your average retro shop with a handful of common titles. Max has built a reputation for sourcing rare, obscure and highly sought-after games. One of the most impressive highlights is that he managed to collect the entire GameCube library (around 651 titles.) That's not just impressive, it's borderline unheard of.
Sure you'll find classics like Mario Kart: Double Dash and Super Smash Bros. Melee, but what makes the collection stand out are the deep cuts, the games most people in the U.S. have never even heard of. These are the kinds of titles that hardcore collectors spend years hunting down.
And the best part is that the inventory is always changing. Every week, customers bring in games to sell or trade, which means there's always something new (or old) to discover. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just getting into retro gaming, there's a sense of excitement every time you walk in.
More Than a Store - A Community Experience
But what really makes Cake Hoarders special isn't just the games, it's the people.
During one visit, I witnessed something that perfectly captured what this place is about. A kid, probably around nine or ten years old, walked in with money he had saved from doing yard work and skipping snacks at school. He had his eye on a Nintendo DS, a system that came out in 2004, long before he was born and could experience it firsthand.
He knew exactly how much it cost and he knew what it was worth to him.
Instead of treating it like a routine sale, Max worked with the kid on the price, making the moment feel meaningful. It wasn't just a transaction, it was an experience. You could see how much it mattered to that kid and honestly, it felt like watching a scene from a movie.
That's the kind of interaction you don’t get from big-box stores or online marketplaces.
Generational Gaming, Why It Matters
For many of us who grew up in the late '90s and early 2000s, these games are more than entertainment, they’re memories. I still remember getting my navy blue Nintendo DS for Christmas in 2004 and spending hours playing with my brother. Seeing a new generation get excited about that same system is something special.
Retro gaming has a unique way of bridging generations. Parents can share the games they grew up with, kids get to experience something completely new (yet old) and suddenly, there’s a shared connection that goes beyond screens.
Cake Hoarders taps into that in a powerful way. It’s not just about reliving the past, it's about passing it on.
Why Turlock Should Care
Now here's the part that matters if you're in Turlock: this isn't just a Modesto thing.
Turlock is only about a 20-minute drive away, but when it comes to niche hobby spaces like retro gaming, options are limited. Cake Hoarders fills a gap that doesn't just serve Modesto, it serves the entire Central Valley.
If you're in Turlock and you: collect retro games, is the feel of old-school gaming, want something unique to do on a weekend or even just want to introduce your kids to the games you grew up with, this spot is worth your time.
Instead of ordering online and hoping for the best, you can actually walk into a store, hold the game in your hands, talk to someone who knows the history behind it and be part of a local community.
That's something you can't replicate digitally.
In a world that's constantly pushing forward, places like this remind us that sometimes, it's worth looking back. Whether you're a lifelong gamer, a curious newcomer, or someone just chasing a bit of nostalgia, Cake Hoarders offers an experience that feels authentic, personal and genuinely fun.
And for those in Modesto and even just down the road in Turlock, it might just become your new favorite spot. So if you haven't visited Cake Hoarder Games yet, this is your sign to check them out and follow them on Instagram for shop updates and deals!
If you're still looking for some great deals, make sure you check out our current deals here at Turlock Self Storage. We’re proud to be recognized as Best in the 209, and as a thank-you to our community, we’re offering:
● First-Year Price Guarantee
Call us today at (209) 934-1412, we'd love to help you!
